And Now For Something Completely Different: Purple Gallinule, Meridian Twp., MI

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

Michigan’s Rare Bird Alert had a posting about an immature purple gallinule that was hanging out in a swampy area of a natural area just NW of the Meridian Mall in Okemos, MI. This particular view shows the brilliant blue and ble-green patches on the bird’s plumage. The white undertail coverts were quite bright and little could be done to tease more detail out of those white feathers. I was shooting handheld through thick cattails from shore. this is an extensive crop so the quality is not as good as it should be.

Feedback Requested

I will probably edit out the bright patches from the surrounding water. Do you think that I should drop down the overall brightness or exposure some more from what I presented?

Technical Details

Camera: Z9
Lens: 180-400mm f4 with TC engaged
Focal length: 560mm
Shutter speed: 1/5000 sec
Aperture: f5.6
ISO: 1600
Flash: Natural Light

Great effort Jim to get any image - and what an unusual bird.

You may be able to make something of a nice reflection in the surface of the water too

Regards
Huw

Nice pose and the colors really pop! As far as a “I actually saw this” shot, it works. A couple of days ago @debbie_campbell and I saw Whooping cranes and basically got things similar - bird shaped things at the back of a field. LOL. The tail position is great and I also like the leg out of the water and the intent look it has. Good job getting out and finding the little guy.

1 Like

Beautiful colors! Great find.

Very cool, Jim. Maybe not an artistic masterpiece, but an excellent documentary image.

Hi Jim

Thank you for the Purple Gallinule. I think the exposure is ok, and as for the white spots. The only two I think you could look at are in the lower third of the frame. Nice low angle.

Peter

Love those colors, Jim. I’d say the detail helped very well despite the crop. I like the reflection and the bent leg. I’d probably remove the white spots in the water. Brightness level looks good.

Thank you @Dennis_Plank , @Kris_Smith , @Huw_Thomas , @Allen_Brooks , @Peter_Morrissey , @Allen_Sparks and @debbie_campbell . I may have a few more shots that could be more artistic in terms of the surrounding elements like reflection and softer light. The colors present in this shot are what made me present this photo. @Allen_Brooks , I agree and I think that removing the white blobs will improve the comp. @Kris_Smith and @debbie_campbell whooping cranes are starting to show up in Michigan too and they are quite photo worthy as well. …Jim

Nice one Jim. A fine pose of this beauty with the bent leg and raised tail. Exposure looks good to me and yes I could see removal of the bright bits. I’ve never seen a juvenile so this is a treat.