Breakfast on the Wing (+revised)

Revised Version

Revision 1 (latest)

What changed: I increased contrast and lightened the brights on the bird (leaving the tail alone) and slightly blurred the yellow bush.

Added after receiving feedback from the community.


Original Version

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

I was watching this Say’s phoebe hunt for a few minutes this morning, and was lucky to capture it catching this bee which it pulled off the rabbitbrush below.

Feedback Requested

Feedback on the composition appreciated - especially cropping. I wanted to include the yellow rabbitbrush.

Technical Details

Camera: OM-1MarkII
Lens: OM 100-400mm F5.0-6.3 + MC-14
Focal length: 334mm
Shutter speed: 1/3200s
Aperture: f/9
ISO: 12800

Wow Debbie, what a fantastic catch and action/flight image! Birds in flight are next level for me! Congrats on this capture!

I think the comp as a result of your cropping is spot on. The important thing beyond wanting to include the rabbit brush, which is important, is that you’ve given plenty of space in front for the bird to fly in to. Maybe a little more room up top, but that’s definitely a personal choice as there is enough room that no tension is created by being to close - if that makes sense.

The only suggestion I have is somehow dropping the lightness of the bird and maybe even increase the contrast. I only mention because the rabbit brush has very nice contrast, appropriate brightness and sharpness. The plant almost competes with the bird. I might try and reverse the attention so the bird gets all the credit.

Very nice and complimentary background too.

Great image!

2 Likes

My kind of bird photo, Debbie. The rabbit bush adds a lot to the image-color, scale, sense of environment. The bird is well positioned in the frame. As Lon mentioned, you might play around with the bird’s contrast. Nice to have the wasp. For me, the plant and bird have equal billing and the two combine to create a pleasing image. Well done to get this shot.

1 Like

Nice capture Debbie. I really like the bokeh and the bush is a must as a supporting actor. The tail of the bird is perfect to me. The rest of him/her is too bright. I think you can even use the PS darkening tool. If you can make the rest of the body like the tail, wow.

1 Like

Very nice capture and square crop works well.

Agree with other suggestions above re brightness of bird.

Lovely colour palette too

Regards

Huw

1 Like

@Huw_Thomas @Allen_Brooks @Lon_Overacker @steve12 Thank you so much for the suggestions, posting a darkened bird and slightly softened rabbitbrush.

The original poster added a revised version of their image.

Yep, for me this makes it a wow. Very beautiful.

1 Like

Wonderful capture and the RP is just right!! Great capture and presentation!

1 Like

Thank you @Diane_Miller and @steve12 :slight_smile:

Excellent job on this, Debbie. It’s a great catch of the action and as noted, the vegetation adds rather than distracts. The repost is spot on.

1 Like

@Dennis_Plank Thank you! I like it better too.

Regarding Revision 1:

Excellent revision, Debbie.

1 Like

Definitely improved bird. Great image Love it
Huw

1 Like

Excellent work on the revision!

1 Like

@Allen_Brooks @Lon_Overacker @Huw_Thomas Thank you :slight_smile:

Hi Deggie

You did a nice job on rebalancing the photograph.

Peter

2 Likes

Hi Debbie, love the bird flying over the flowers and great to see the bee in the mouth. Love the fanned out tail also. Pleasing background. Nice job on the revision.