Fall Spot Light

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

In the fall the Autumn Glory Maple trees at the Ahtanum Mission (which is located about 15 miles west of Yakima on the way to Tampico) turn many different colors but the most striking are the reds. This was taken of the shady side of one, but with a bit of sun shinning through to highlight a small area.

Feedback Requested

Usually I prefer taking wide angle shots of the trees that line an entrance road and full tree shots. I took more intimate shots to demonstrate that their beauty can be shown without wider views. Does placing the bright leaves in the middle cause concern?

Technical Details

Canon R5; 100/400 @ 400; F16; Daylight; 1/250th sec.; ISO 1600.

This is spectacular, Jim. I like it as presented. I did some “scroll-cropping” and found some really nice compositions that are 4x5 or square, placing the lit leaves in the upper left third. I don’t have a problem with them being centered; it works. But when they are in the upper left and the frame is more square, the image feels less contextualized and a little more ethereal. This is just a screen capture, but something along these lines is worth considering, maybe a little more off the left. I think it has something to do with removing the branch above the lit leaves. It’s a matter of taste, for sure.

Looking forward to seeing what others suggest.

ML

Marylynne, I like the square crop. I didn’t even think of it, but I did try cropping some from the top to move it off center and like that, too. Wonder how many versions there can be.

1 Like

This is stunning. I love the small area of light. It must have been fun to search around the tree at 400mm to find compelling images. I agree with @Marylynne_Diggs that a tighter crop might enhance the image a bit. I’m not personally real big on 1:1’s but I do think bringing the edges in and keeping the sunlit leaves about where they are would look nice. We’ve just had a big ol’ snowstorm followed by a solid freeze, so our leaves are dropping like crazy. I hope to get out one more time this weekend and look for any spots of color that may be left!

Jim: I love light like this and the possibilities it brings. I do think a tighter crop would give more emphasis to the lit leaves as they’re notable but a little lost in the expanse of the frame. I do like that how ever you crop the bright leaves are the clear star of the show. Nicely done. >=))>

@Paul_Holdorf @Bill_Fach Thank you for your comments. I love having four defined seasons here, and fall is my favorite, although the other three are wonderful, too.

Absolutely gorgeous find and execution, Jim. I like Marylynne’s crop suggestion so I thought I’d throw in another as the slightly brighter leaves along the top and the out of focus leaves at the bottom felt like they were disturbing the image.

P.S. A few of us from our local camera club are headed over to the Ag Museum in Union Gap this weekend and I think I’ll have to add the mission to my itinerary.

Visual Notes

[Crop] Remove the slightly brighter leaves at the upper right and most of the out of focusleaves on the bottom. Put the brightly lit leaves and the next tier down on a diagonal.

1 Like

Beautiful color and light here. While the various crops are quite nice, I like the crop @Dennis_Plank did the best. It really allows the nice light and color of the spotlit leaves to be the star of the show.

It’s a wonderful image, Jim!
-P

Jim, the spot lighting on those few leaves is wonderful. I like the original because it emphasizes how unique that little section. I think you placed it well, with the cluster just a bit off center.

Sometimes here in Montana it feels like we have just two seasons; Autinter and Sprummer :zany_face:

Lovely image and I very much love Dennis’ crop

huw

Jim, not sure where you see the other 3 seasons. Would you mind showing me?

Beautiful image in terms of color. However I have a question and suggestion.

Where are the other colors?

Suggestion is that I would like to see more sun in different locations or see the sun actually represented because I honestly cannot tell that it’s the sun causing the light. It could be flash or some other light source. But, love the beet red leaves. They remind me of our Japanese :maple_leaf: Maple.