The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive
About This Image
This photograph was made in the Stinson Flats area of Washington state during the recent PNW Regional Group meetup. I was original drawn to the beauty of the colorful leaf, but I stayed with the subject a bit longer because of the character in the dried up leaves behind it.
Feedback Requested
I’m mostly participating in the weekly challenge, but I’m always open to any and all feedback. In particular:
Do the specular highlights distract too much? I felt they were central to the experience of the location, but I’m not sure they work in presentation.
What about the oof trees?
Do you see a better crop, maybe just the bottom 2/3rds in a more horizontal aspect ratio?
Thanks as always for any thoughts you have on my work,
Marylynne, the red/green combination in the leaves is a fine attention grabber. The dead leaves in the cluster add well to the “story”. I think you could have gotten closer with that lens to get a view just that of the main branch and it’s leaves, although that might have required a stack to get the entire collection of leaves sharp.
Looks very ‘christmas’ like - the main subject stands out well. I would consider toning down the brighter background and erhaps even cropping some - my 2 cents…
Thanks @Mark_Seaver and @Karl_Zuzarte.
Mark: I have a few from closer in, but I kind of hate stacking. I should give it another shot one of these days. I was trying to get that oof background without losing the crispness of the leaf cluster.
Karl: I wondered if a horizontal crop might create a better sense of being there. I like the dappled light in the background as it promotes that sense of being in the woods and blinking through the shade and sun.
Certainly not a wall hanger, but a slight revision will be posted above momentarily.
Marlynne, Oak leave are a favorite of mine this time of year and I particularly like your revision. You still have the wonderful dried leaves in the background. The oof trees in the background look fine to me, they give context but aren’t the focal point. The star of the show is the color and shape of the leaves, like a little bouquet in the forest.
I like this image a lot , Marylynne. The only thing that bugs me a bout it a little is the bright bokeh balls to our right and below the main leaf cluster. I downloaded your image a stuck it into LR for some minor adjustments, masking for the background and intersecting it with a luminosity mask to get the highlights. I’m including a screen shot of the adjustments I made for reference.
Dennis: I see what you mean about how bright that bokeh is. On my pc, it looks fine (all brighter overall), but even now on my phone I’m like “eesh, I gotta tone that down!” Thanks for the demo ! I almost never use luminosity range as my mask choice. I’m going to explore it today.