Photobombed

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

First mushroom focus stack this year - 3rd EVER! mushroom stack

Was photobombed by fly - who managed to photobomb the right segments.

Feedback Requested

Suggestions for improvements always welcome

Technical Details

Camera: A7v
Lens:100mm GM
Focal length: 100mm
Shutter speed: 1/250
Aperture:f/9
ISO:3200
Flash:yes TTL -1 ev
Focusstack 50 images - used the middle 20, flash went off in all. Used Incamera Focus stack 2x25
Camera propped on stones on floor - Yes I will remember tripod next time!

2 Likes

Good use of flash to separate subject from background and make it jump off the virtual page. The fly adds some interest but IMHO detracts from subject of challenge which already suffered. I get mushroom sprouts in my yard all spring, summer, and fall so despite artistic merits not sure image adheres to challenge.

1 Like

Hi George

What challenge?

Huw

Uh oh. Now you’ve done it. New addiction coming up! Stacking was a game changer for me and fungi photography. Welcome to the club.

I like the addition of the crazy mosses that got disturbed during the fruiting. The two smaller mushrooms are a nice addition and I quite like the fly. They are all over certain species and I love it when I can “fix” one into place from one source image. The exposure looks ok, but some hot spots in the leading edge and the split inside bit on the right. I wonder if using 2nd curtain flash would ease up on the harsh shadows left by the flash (the leaf on the right for example, has a big shadow that feels out of kilter). Oh and 3200 ISO? With a flash that seems odd…??

Composition wise, I would have explored leaving the split out to see if it was more or less interesting without it. I also would have removed some of the leaves in the fg, especially the one in front of our littlest soldier. Also to maybe get the three mushrooms in more of a line across the image rather than from front to back. Sometimes that introduces more problems either with fore or backgrounds, so YMMV, but it always pays to fiddle around with it. Sometimes I use my phone to do this rather than setting up the camera and tripod, it’s faster. As it is, maybe clone out the bright bit on the left and tone down the bright gray OOF leaf on the bottom left.

Overall a nice look at the forest floor which is always a great place to be.

1 Like

@Kris_Smith
Many thanks for all the advice - will digest slowly.
The high iso was because the flash was 1/32 power - so it didn’t take long recycling

I have some LED lights which I must try

Will think about 2nd curtain flash too

Lots to think about

Many thanks

Huw

Nice composition with the background and subject. The fly adds some reference to the size of the mushroom. I would favor moving the right side edge more to the left enough to remove the brown OOF left making a portrait. Nice image, Huw

1 Like

Thanks @Dean_Salman
Huw

Huw: When I first saw the thumbnail I thought sure it was going to be from @Kris_Smith so I hope you know I mean that as a high compliment. This looks pretty darn good to me. Before the term photo bomber joined the lexicon we would call the fly a party crasher. I think it adds a lot. I’ll defer to Kris regarding stacking and comp but overall I think you did great. >=))>

1 Like

I like the comp with the fly perched on the mushroom. The OOF elements at the bottom of the frame caught my eye and wish that the entire basal are of the mushrooms were not hidden by this area. For improving your flash use, you can deliberately under-expose the scene to eliminate hot spots. You can then bump up the exposure, shadows, and highlights in Lightroom. Dropping the ISO down will also help. Remember that when using ttl settings on a flash, the camera will always try to tell the flash to produce the best average lighting for the scene. Use manual flash settings and adjust the camera’s aperture and exposure time to produce the best photo. Also, with today’s digital cameras, under-exposing images is not a deal breaker concerning noise…Jim

1 Like

Photobombed image. Maybe it wasn’t for a challenge I apologize.

1 Like

No worries

@Huw_Thomas was the image not submitted for a weekly challenge?

Nope - no worries - if you look at the tags at the top by the title you’ll see whether its tagged for the challenge or not - not always clear, really not bothered :smiley:

Huw

Nice mushroom photo with that surprise visitor in sharp focus on top of the largest one. I like how you have three separate mushrooms, with the size decreasing towards the bottom. The main point of interest being the caps is sharp, with a nice falloff to make the background soft. Well done.

Great image, Huw! I love the surpirse visitor. The mosses around the mushroom look like they’ve just been pushed aside. I wonder if you could have moved slightly left or right to include the bottom of the mushrooms and avoid the biggish OOF brown thing.

I wish I could give you sage advice on flash, stacking and such things. It’s out of my wheel-house.

1 Like

Thanks Glenys - enjoying learning new things too, and eager to try some artistic interpretations too.
I like everything sharp (the point of stacking) but might try something unusual - Mono/ a bit of Orton ? who knows??

Huw

Thanks Ted