Red Baneberry at dawn (+revised)

Revised Version

Revision 1 (latest)

What changed: I removed the dark stems, reduced the whites and lowered the exposure in the leaves in the background, added a slight vignette. Better?

Added after receiving feedback from the community.


Original Version

Weekly Challenge

The Sound of Silence
7/26/26 - 8/1/26
Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic + Technical

About This Image

This is one of my first images to post to the group. Looking forward to your feedback!

Feedback Requested

I’m very open to your comments. I’ve been taking photos deliberately for a couple of years now and would love to improve in all aspects.

Technical Details

Camera: OM-5MarkII
Lens: OM 20mm F1.4
Focal length: 20mm
Shutter speed: 1/80s
Aperture: f/2.2
ISO: 200

Hi and welcome to NPN if I haven’t already hit you with that on another thread. Lately I’ve been noticing and photographing these taller understory plants so I really like the subject you chose. Photos of more unnoticed environmental plants are such fun. I think I took a photo of this same plant in my yard when it was flowering, but I missed the fruits, so good on you.

Visual Notes

[1] Bright foliage draws my eye first - changing position or using a polarizer can cut down on this type of thing. Here’s a discussion on using a polarizer for close up work.

[A1] Dark stem distracting - maybe moving more in front of these two branches would help if there wasn’t anything worse in frame by that change.

[2] All these missing berries - purpose? If you’re after more of a lifecycle shot, this is a good addition to the story - I wonder what eats them since I believe they are toxic. Makes you wonder.

If you wanted a more pretty or beautiful type of photo rather than a documentarian version, you could eliminate the taller stem and just focus on the one with more berries. You didn’t talk about your field technique, but often a tripod helps with composition while you evaluate the scene and remove distractions by changing position or holding things out of the way. I often do this and arrive at a final composition after several tries and checks on the screen to show me what’s working and what isn’t. It can also allow for latitude with settings like a smaller aperture or different shutter speed. All food for thought! Hope it was helpful.

1 Like

This feedback was REALLY helpful. Thank you Kristen! Exactly what I was looking for. And thanks to the link on using a polarizer. Much appreciated.

The original poster added a revised version of their image.

1 Like

Steve: Ditto @Kris_Smith on the welcome and the comments. I think the revision is a significant improvement and very nicely done. Great to have you aboard and looking forward to more of your work. >=))>

1 Like

Steve, welcome to NPN. This is a fine view of these Baneberries, with a good spotlight effect. Removing the dark stems is a good improvement. I think the dark vignette is going too far, but that’s a personal decision. Part of what you want to learn is how to take the variety of opinions and use them for your own creative growth.

1 Like

Hi Steve! Beautifully simple image. The combination of colors is terrific. While the revisions you made were small, they were very effective. Well done!!

1 Like