The Brave Oak

Latest Version:

Original:

Michael’s version:

Marylynne’s Version:

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

I wanted to change my perspective by shooting with side lighting. The tufts of smoke on the ground showed greater tonal range which I found attractive. This one has been rendered darker because I’m not shooting directly into the sunlight. And finally I just liked the color of the tree itself. It’s sort of a reddish brown and I like how it stood out against the cool smoke. The composition is not very imaginative.

Feedback Requested

“I’m wondering whether the mood or feeling I was aiming for comes through”. I suppose all of these fire images are about mood and this one is no different.

Any suggestion is helpful. The subject is not as veiled as in previous images. Is that to its detriment?

Technical Details

Camera: FUJIFILM GFX 50R
Focal length: 45mm
Shutter speed: 1/100s
Aperture: f/11
ISO: 160

Hi Igor,

I feel like the mood of this picture is survival and defiance. The tree in the center seems to have survived an ordeal, while the the background is basically black and white silhouettes. The amount of space allotted above the center tree shows the scale of the survivor.

You mentioned that you like the color of the center tree; I can see it but it isn’t very distinct. Have you considered trying to lighten the tree to bring out more color? Or perhaps did you get a second exposer that is lighter that can be combined with this one? I think that would depend on the mood you’re going for. If you introduce too much color there, it would change the mood somewhat.

All-in-all, I like it a lot.

1 Like

Thanks Jim. I feel the tree has to stay dark relative to the background. I could make it a bit lighter. I think saturating it might be good. I’ll try that. Thanks.

This is really good! I love the light, the mood and I think the centered composition works really nicely here. The only thing that I would change would be to get rid of that tiny bit of branch in the top right corner.

I find this image very attractive. It gives me a sense of grandiosity, permanence, resistance. Also of proudness without any negative downsides. Difficult to explain why, but the picture, the light, the contrasts create a balanced and very captivating picture, at least for me. Excellent vision and realization.

I like the fact that the tree is not as veiled as some of the others. Makes it stand out more in it’s bravery to survive. I lightened the tree a little. Didn’t seem to improve it any imho. Doing a little edge patrol, I would get rid of the branch in the URC. Nice image.

Thank you Michael. I posted it at the top. The difference must be very small because I am having trouble seeing it.

Hi Igor,

I’m enjoying this series from the burns near Trout Lake. I like the tiny bit of brightening and also like the idea of removing the branch tip at the upper right corner. It might just be me, but the heavy trunk on the lower left edge competed with your brave oak. I played with a 3:2 crop to eliminate it while retaining the smoking stump to its right. I think a 5x7 could also work. I wasn’t sure what to keep/lose with a more complete crop (hence the bit of white frame at the top and bottom). But I think this might retain all the important elements with fewer distractions. For some reason, it seemed to make the smoke in the lower left a bit brighter, so that might need to be toned down a tiny tiny bit.

As always, feel free to disregard. A scene like this should be messy to some extent, so I’m not sure it needs to be tidied, but you know me…

ML

Thank you Marylynne. I had also thought about that intruding trunk and whether to remove it. I posted your version above as a comparison after adding a white frame. I find comparing framed with unframed difficult. It is a simpler more straightforward image now. It’s also a bit narrower. I have mixed feelings about that trunk. It bothered me and it didn’t bother me. Perhaps it might be best to make prints of both and give them time. One thing I like about that trunk is that it gives a sense of depth in that the smoke appears behind it and not bordering the frame itself. There is a space between the tree and that trunk that invites you in and explore the smoke. I worked on that idea in later images some more.

Incidentally I must’ve taken a picture of this tree several different times during the shoot. Some with more smoke and others with less. I chose the once with less but the suggestions that the darks should be lightened has me rethinking that. What do you think? I guess I just got tired of hazy compositions. I never liked them all that much to begin with.

1 Like

I like the less hazy image that you started with Igor and really don’t have much to add except that the subject fits very well in these conditions, since the oak is pretty fire resistant and even if the tree looks dead it will often resprout from the roots.

Another beautiful signature Igor photo! I would consider popping the red some!

This tree looks like it belongs in the smoky scene to me. My 2 cents worth :-/