The descent (+revised)

Revised Version

Revision 1 (latest)

What changed: Lightened up a bit around the bear and the bear’s eyes.

Added after receiving feedback from the community.


Original Version

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

We were floating in a raft down Moraine Creek up in the Katmai National Preserve when we came in this brown bear carefully making his way down the slope on the side of the creek. It was great fun to watch him move closer and notice us as we floated past.

Feedback Requested

I would appreciate any thoughts regarding general composition, framing and suggestions on how to make the photo better. Thanks.

Technical Details

Canon 7Dm2
EF 100-400
ISO 2500. 400mm. f6.3. 1/3200

1 Like

Timothy, the framing and comp. look great. I really like how those huge claws show. The scattered flowers add interest around the frame. You might try some dodging of the dark are below the head as it’s so much darker than everything else in the frame.

Your comp is spot on and like having lots, but not too much space for the bear’s movement. I agree with mark in that you could work on the dark shadowed area of the bear and surroundings. Love those claws! The greens look good and the surrounding habitat does fit the grizzly quite well. Great shot…Jim

I like the pose and the action in this image, Timothy, and the composition works quite well. When I look at the larger image the claws and grasses seem to have a slight haze around them, like you applied a glow effect of some sort. It’s not noticeable unless one is pixel peeping. I agree with @Mark_Seaver on the darker area and you might try sneaking just a tad more light into the eyes, but you’re almost at the realistic limit there, so it can’t be very much.

A fine image.

Hi Timothy,

Wonderful natural capture of this bear. I can feel its lumbering walk, and I love how it’s got you in its line of sight without looking directly at you. I see what others mean about the dark area beneath the bear’s head. I think it’s the bear’s shadow, as it looks like the sun is coming in over the left side of its shoulder. Maybe a slight doding there? But not so much as to take away that sense of walking in the sun. I agree that a slight brightening of eyes might be nice.

Nicely done,

ML

Thanks Mark. I appreciate your thoughts and advice.

Thanks Jim. Great recommendation.

Thanks Dennis for your thoughts. Interestingly I do see what you are talking about around the claws but I did not do any glow. I’ll have to go back and review the original image.

Marylynne, thank you for your thoughts. I agree that probably most of the dark area is the bear’s shadow. I’ll try to lighten a little but not too much​:grinning_face:

The original poster added a revised version of their image.

Beautiful image, I love that touch of pink and purple flowers. Those claws really stand out and repost looks better.

Thank you J