The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive
About This Image
Just finished a wonderful few days in Yosemite organized by Lon Overacker. This afternoon was my last day there and I decided to hike up to Vernal Falls. There’s been some rain so the waterfalls are active although nowhere close to spring volumes. I’d been to Yosemite twice before, in April of 2001 and October of 2008. Both times I did the hike to Vernal Falls so I thought I would give it a go. I thought I remembered having a clear view of the falls from the bridge over the Merced about .8 miles up the trail. When I got there after barely beating a couple of snails up the trail I recalled that one can see the falls from the bridge but only a portion of them and they’re pretty small. Well I was there and even though the full light on the falls I saw from the bridge was fading I decided that I’d gone this far so why not go all the way. Sometimes I think I get stupider as I get older. That last section was a sea level lung and leg buster! The snails won that part of the trek. But I had plenty of light to get some interesting extracts from the falls and was surprised to see this sly devil peeking out.>=))>
Feedback Requested
How about the rocks in the LRC? I think they’re of a sufficient size to fit into the scene and they don’t pull my eye. Your thoughts? Any suggestions for improvement most welcome.
Technical Details
Sony A7rIII
Sony FE 70-200 f2.8 GM-II @ 173mm, CPL
ISO 400, 1/10 @ f8
Global adjustments in LRC, final sizing and detailing in PS
LOL, love your story of how you got this shot!! I’m really drawn to the curve of the rocks in the center of the frame and how it reaches left along the top ridge. It’s a beautiful composition as is.
I sure understand how you feel, Bill. We were up on the Olympic Peninsula coast a week ago and I passed on Ruby Beach just thinking about climbing back up that slope.
The rocks in the lower right do pull my eye a bit-maybe try just darkening them a touch? It is a cute little devil.
Very nice, Bill! Props for hiking up the trail. On first viewing I didn’t even notice those rocks. The light from the water drew my eye to the left. But since you mentioned it, I agree with Bill about darkening them a bit. Great to meet you!
Bill, I like the mistiness of the falls and the fascinating details in the rocks (both the beast lurking in the lower left corner) and the angled shapes in brown, behind the falls, in the center. The rocks on the right don’t bother me as they contrast well with the softness and mistiness elsewhere. You could emphasize my favorite parts with a crop to 4x5, losing things on the right.
This is a lovely intimate look at a section of Vernal Falls. I had to smile while reading your description of your hike up the trail as that is how I feel sometimes while hiking. We just have to keep on moving. This scene has a quiet serene vibe that I find very inviting. I am also enjoying the veils of water; perfect SS for my tastes. I too see that sly devil peeking out at you. My only suggestion would to to slightly darken those rocks in the LRC. Beautifully done.
I have always loved telephoto crops into the details of waterfalls and this one gets a thumbs up! Perfect amount of water and shutter speed! The rocks are fine for me but maybe darken them a little. I would clone out the top round one – it is an eye magnet.
I have been observing snails over the years and am convinced they have evolved to be faster.
Love the water action here and the devil lurking within. The rocks to the right didn’t bother me until you mentioned them. I’m glad we were not shooting together at that point. I did my best to hike as little as possible last week.
The rocks on the lower right are interesting because they’re both an eyesore and they add to the image. The act like a counterpoint. It would have been better if the one large rock was included completely rather than shaved off.
A bit late, for which I shouldn’t be… I got home before you did. But first, it was so great meeting you and shooting with you and the others. I’m so glad you made the trek out from Texas! And second, kudos for making the hike up the Mist trail! Very impressed! You put all of us “younger” folks to shame!
To the image - fantastic! I just love the combo and blance between the silky cascade and the fascinating rock. The colorful earth tones are wonderful as well. Some don’t like silky… but for me it’s always a case-by-case basis and I love the shutter speed here.
As far as the LRC rocks, I’m a bit with Igor - it’s either a blessing or a curse. With the slight burning, the repost is better. I think you’ve included enough of them that it comes across as intentional (not an oversight). I’m guessing, another step to the left might have been deadly, so I think you did well with this capture and framing.
I hesitate posting this revision simply because for most folks, it goes too far with the advanced AI remove features… but I did crop from the right and use the content-aware replace. The sw tools are just amazing now! (But I struggle with my own mantra… “just because you can do something, doesn’t mean you should…”) I’ll just leave it there.
Love the image regardless; processing is spot on. So glad you got the posts going - a great, all be it, truncated trip for most of us!