The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive
About This Image
In searching for photos that show subtle motion, I found some showing the growth on the bottom of the stream that’s part of my water garden, where the sky/light reflections show the motion, while other part were stationary. This one was taken this morning with a recently fallen Oak leaf catching some sun, while a mix of fall colors and sky reflections adds surrounding interest while quietly showing the water’s movement.
Feedback Requested
I’m quite happy with the result which shows good detail in the main leaf, the briefly trapped bubble with sunstars and lots of colorful flow structures in the water.
The bubble is tack sharp and it is nice to see crisp sun stars. The OOF patterns with a hint of blue from the surrounding moving water add significantly to the scene, The diagonal formed by the submerged leaf and subject produced an eye-pleasing comp. I think that this photo is fine as presented…Jim
A gorgeous image, Mark. I’m not sure about the sense of movement. Though it shows up in the ripples, the leaf and bubble tend to dominate the image for me. I do get a feel of quiet from it. I’m finding it interesting in this challenge how difficult it seems to be to get both in a single image.
This is a classic shot. I especially like the clarity of the bubble on the exposed leaf, and the subtle connection with the submerged leaf in the background. The colour definitely gives this image a late season feel. Even the water’s warm tones complement the subject.
This is really beautiful. I love the light and the colour and the way the texture of the leaf contrasts with the texture of the water around it. No nits from me.