The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive
About This Image
The bald cypress at Trap Pond SP, DE were absolutely beautiful this year during our day visit and IMO at peak color. While walking around the pond these lovely colorful reflections caught my eye and I hope I did them justice. When their needles turn this beautiful orange color; during the autumn season; it rivals the fall foliage colors of deciduous trees IMO.
Feedback Requested
Just wondering if you prefer the uncropped version or the pano and why. Anything else you notice please feel free to mention it.
My preference is for the un-cropped version. Mostly because it feels a bit more abstract and I do enjoy abstract nature. Either one is lovely and the colors are so well balanced between the warm fall folaige and the cool trunks. Very nicely done
Simply gorgeous, Ed. More and more I’m starting to really enjoy these reflections at Trap Pond when the water has a little movement versus a mirror reflection. You know I gotta be super nit picky. I would clone out the dark spot right in the middle that looks like a dust spot. Don’t think it is, but resembles one. And also that bright reflection near the bottom.
I like both. The colors are excellent. The reflection is appealing as well. I might consider a crop the has as much of the tree trunks above water as there is in the reflection.
The uncropped version for me as well Ed, because I enjoy the branches and leaves. Beautiful colors and reflections. It’s interesting how the group on the right are reflected differently than the group on the left.
I tend to prefer the cropped version, Ed. It’s probably a personal quirk, but the way the three trees on the right lean to the right while the ones on the left appear to be pretty much vertical, just drives my eyes nuts. The crop removes that issue. I also like @John_Williams’s bit of whimsy.
I’m late to the party on this one, but I love both images (well, all three, if you count John’s nuclear option). The colors are magnificent and the feet of these cypress seem like they offer endless possibilities. I like the branches cross the frame in the uncropped version, and I like that the cropped version retains some of those lovely red leaves. Good news, you have at least 4 good photographs in one here. I don’t know what the fourth would be, but I bet you can carve one out if you have a mind to.
Simply a gorgeous scene Ed! I’m really enjoying the clean and unblemished isolation and crop (not just the pano) you’ve captured here.
As far as that pano crop goes, if I was going to crop and crop in to the reflection at all, I wouldn’t crop so much from the cypress trees. I think your crop went too far in the trees. I’d say just a trim off the top, bottom and left side (not the right).
The only other suggestion I have would be in the personal choice realm, and that would be more saturation and maybe even contrast? A little bit of Orton wouldn’t hurt, if you’re so inclined.
For sure, a gorgeous scene giving you numerous options. Beautiful!
Hi Ed, both are nice, but I definitely prefer the uncropped version. You get more of the beautiful orange needles in the uncropped, plus I find the pano format to be less functional, if that’s the right word. Harder to frame, has less visual presence than the uncropped version at the same width. Obviously that’s just personal preference, though, and the composition does work very well in your pano.
I love the orange and grey/green color palette of these cypress ponds, and you’ve captured a pleasing amount of both of those in the uncropped version. The balance of sharp trees to blurred reflection looks perfect to me. I hope you have more images to come from here!