The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic + Technical
About This Image
When I was at the Central Washington Agricultural Museum weekend before last, there was a hedge of sumac in full blown autumn color and I spent some time doing ICMs and straight images of it. This is an attempt to blend the two. Sumac has always given me a tropical vibe and this patch in particular gave that impression, so that was what I was trying to create here.
Feedback Requested
I was trying to give this the feel of a tropical rain forest,except in shades of yellow and red instead of green. Does any of that come through to you?
Technical Details
Image 1
Camera: SONY ILCE-7RM5
Lens: FE 70-200mm F4 Macro G OSS II
Focal length: 200mm
Shutter speed: 1/4s
Aperture: f/22
ISO: 100
Ripple base image
Camera: SONY ILCE-7RM5
Lens: FE 70-200mm F4 Macro G OSS II
Focal length: 200mm
Shutter speed: 1/4s
Aperture: f/22
ISO: 100
sumac base image
Camera: SONY ILCE-7RM5
Lens: FE 70-200mm F4 Macro G OSS II
Focal length: 200mm
Shutter speed: 1/13s
Aperture: f/22
ISO: 200
The ripple layer was the base layer. I added a white layer over it and reproduced the ripple layer above it at reduced opacity. The Sumac layer was on top and was combined using the color burn blending mode. Opacity of the upper ripple layer was adjusted to get the amount of texture I was trying to achieve. I exported back to LR, made some color adjustments to the right side of the image where it was a bit too yellow for my taste and a linear gradient to brighten the left side.
Dennis, the mix of movement with hidden shapes makes for interesting viewing. I like the effect, but find myself wishing that the clear shapes were a bit more hidden (lots of room to play with the mix here…). I do find the three more yellow areas pulling my eyes(upper right, bottom left). I think some mid-tone burning there for darkening with more contrast would let them blend better with the rest of the view.
Great color and creativity here, Dennis. In the “thumbnail” and on an iPhone, the opacity of layers felt about perfect, but on a bigger screen, I can see Mark’s point. I think a little more density of the ripple base frame would take this up a notch.
The colors look great to my eye: very autumnal and warm. The lighter yellows might disappear if you do a vertical flip of the ripple base frame before the blending. That would place the greater density of leaves in the the ripple base over the lower density of leaves in the sumac base (does that make sense?)
As for the tropical question, I’m not sure I get that sense. Maybe I’ve been in too many green tropics, so part of it is that I don’t necessarily associate orange with the tropics (Tropicana aside).
Nice work here. I’m hoping you have more coming too!
Thanks, @Mark_Seaver and @Marylynne_Diggs for your input. I played with the midtones and flipping the curtain layer, Marylynne but didn’t get it quite where I wanted it. It will have to set on the back burner and simmer for awhile.
1 Like
Marylynne_Diggs
(Marylynne Diggs)
selected this as an Editor's Pick
5
Seasonal color palette and interesting experiment with layering exposures.
Liking an abstract is often a matter of taste, I think, and this is just my cup of tea. Your process is a bit complex for my old Photoshop CS6, I think, but this certainly encourages me to experiment with blending a “normal” and ICM shot. The end result here is very cool. Good that it got an EP too!
Hi Mike. The major effect was just done with layers blending modes, which I think were around on CS6, though I just discovered them a year or two ago. When you add a layer, this is what the layers palette looks like:
Just click on the down arrow after the “normal” to get the full list of options. If I’m wrong and it’s not there, let me know as it’s been some time since I used that version.
Dennis, I have to say I am blown away with the top image. It resonates so much for me because at first glance my mind went to sandstone wall in the desert southwest. Probably because I just spent 2 months in Utah and several time I experimented with shooting some of the textures in the sandstone cliffs/walls around the various arches.
So for me, had I not seen where you started with, I thought I was looking at textured rock, which makes your image all the more mesmerizing for me. I would not change a thing, Excellent work!