Half Dome Pre Dawn

Critique Style: Initial Reaction

Please share your first response before reading the hidden notes below. The photographer is looking for an unbiased initial impression.

Feedback Focus: Artistic + Technical

Questions for Viewers

Curious about your impression of this photo. I’m new to this artistic community and would love feedback.

About This Image

It was really quite dark when I took this shot a the pull off just before Tunnel View. Handheld, just jumped out of the car for a quick shot. The pre dawn clouds were quite striking, but I accidentally had the camera on an “artistic mode” that created most of the color. I kinda like it. My partner hates it. My photographer nephew loves it. What about you?

Technical Details

Camera: OM-5MarkII
Lens: OM 14-150mm F4.0-5.6 II
Focal length: 100mm
Shutter speed: 1/13s
Aperture: f/5.6
ISO: 6400

Feedback Requested

What did you feel? Is this artistic?

Hi Steve,
These colors are lovely, but I’m focusing mostly on the sky and that fantastic pair of lenticular clouds. I am not the best at digital color management (I rely on my camera and my pc, which is not necessarily calibrated, along with a natural sensitivity to minor hue shifts and color temperature). To me, half dome looks a bit blue maybe? I feel like I see a bit of color fringe too, but that could be a bit of blur from shooting hand-held at sunset :sweat_smile:

I’ve only been to Yosemite once, in 2017, and it was so smoky that I couldn’t see anything from Tunnel View. Yeah, I was seriously disappointed.

We have lots of Yosemite experts here, and folks who are good with how to do something artistic with color without making it look too artificial (unless you want it to look artificial, which is fine too). To me, this strikes a good balance. I’ll be curious to see what others think.
ML

1 Like

Hi Steve,

First of all, WELCCOME to NPN! Glad to have you here and that you’ve joined the community. As Marylynne mentioned, lots of Yosemite afficianodos here, including myself.

This is classic - and in a couple of ways. A classic viewpoint off of 120 coming in to the park. I love how the mountains and monoliths are compressed together - ie. Half Dome and El Capitan. This is also classic really in the definition of the “blue hour.” Also a classic exposure challenge! With the sky just getting brigher with each passing moment, the landscape is left in shadow for quite a while.

I think you did a great job composing this. I also think you handled the exposure well given the dynamics. The challenge comes in how best to process the image and portray the colors as best you remember and experienced. The good news is, when it comes to color/saturation, etc., it’s very subjective and often personal.

I think the colors in the sky above half dome, the pinks, lavenders, etc. are just about perfect and quite natural. For me personally, it’s the blues that are the challenge. And actually the blue in the URC, upper right corner, looks pretty good. It’s the ULC corner that is drawing my eye and thus distracting. It almost looks like there’s some vignetting going on, but with a longer focal length, I don’t see that happening. Anyway, my suggestion might be to process it in such a way that the two upper corners are much closer in color, saturation and luminosity. One clue is that direction, east, is where the sun would be rising and I wouldn’t think from this vantage point there would be a difference in those two corners.

The “blue hour” light/color on Half Dome is a little more realistic, but again a personal choice. I might dial back the blue a couple of points.

It’s hard to tell, but lastly it looks like El Cap and the foreground ridges are lacking in some detail. I expect possibly it’s the jpg compression and/or the size you posted? Hopefully you’ve got a good raw file where more detail might be present.

Hope this wasn’t too harsh. You’ve got a gorgeous sky. I think with some tweaking the rest of the image could be made to match the greatness of the sky. Hope that makes sense.

Welcome aboard! We look forward to you images and participation!

edit: your comments explain a few things… :slight_smile:

Welcome Steve. Pretty cool for a grab shot. I love the sky colors and the compression effect from the longer focal length. The blue on Half Dome could be dialed back a little I feel. I do wish for a little more detail in the mountainsides. Is that an effect from the artistic mode the camera was in?

Oh, thank you! Exactly what I was looking for. Much appreciated!

Yes, the artistic mode doesn’t give an option for any settings, it makes all the choices. And thanks for the kudos and comments!

Excellent lighting and colors in this shot. It all works for me.

1 Like