A Touch of Tartan

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic + Technical

About This Image

Walking through a local park, I twitched at some of the flowers. This one pleased my eye the most, and I thought it had a Scottish flavor to it.

Feedback Requested

Is there enough harmony in the arrangement to make for an attractive ICM? If not, could it be improved?

Technical Details

Camera: OM-1
Focal length: 60mm
Shutter speed: 1/6s
Aperture: f/14
ISO: 80

Tonal treatment in LR and PS, followed by cropping.

Excellent ICM work, Mike. Great color palette. I find this an attractive abstract. A black frame might give it a fine art look.

Hi Mike,

This gorgeous. I love the color palette and the crescent arcs. I’m camping this weekend so I just have the “iPhone view,” but I rotated the phone and found that the image also works (not better but differently) with a clockwise rotation, making the swoops little domes.

Nicely done!

ML

Hi Mike,

Love this abstract! The combination of colors along with the alternating arcs is effective and interesting. It does exactly what an abstract should…invites you to wonder:o)

Well done! Holly

very bright and cheerful ICM
Amazing colours.
I like it very much

Huw

@Holly_Lehr @Huw_Thomas @Allen_Brooks @Marylynne_Diggs . Thanks for your kind comments. I like the idea of Tartan Hills, Marylynne.

Mike: Ditto to all of the above. Nicely conceived and a delightful result. >=))>

Mike, this is nicely bright and cheerful and there is a bit of tartan colors here. I too was wondering how a 90° right rotation would look.

This works for me, Mike. I’ve seen flannel shirts that look just about this gaudy. While I’d probably never wear this pattern, it looks very cool on the screen.

1 Like

I can see John Daly wearing it!

So dynamic and cheery. I love the curving lines and layers of color. I agree about trying a clockwise rotation. Good either way, but I think the rotation would appeal to me more.

1 Like