Anther (+revised)

Revised Version

Revision 1 (latest)

What changed: Blurred anther a little more on edge

Added after receiving feedback from the community.


Original Version

Critique Style: Initial Reaction

Please share your first response before reading the hidden notes below. The photographer is looking for an unbiased initial impression.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

Questions for Viewers

ICM and soft focus - all about suggested shapes , form and light.
Hopefully just enough in focus to make the scene suggestive and recognisable

About This Image

Evening Primrose caught in morning light

Technical Details

Camera: A7iv
Lens: Canon MP-E 65mm 1-5x
Focal length: 65mm
Shutter speed:1/125
Aperture:f/5
ISO:1090
Flash:no

Feedback Requested

does it work as an ICM soft focus arty image??

Huw: Mellow Yellow! Great selective focus and just enough tonal separation to make this a fine capture. Well conceived, seen, captured and presented. >=))>

A very interesting composition, Huw. I like the soft focus on this one. I’m a bit ambivalent about the composition with the upper right anther being apparently sharpest and point out of the frame-maybe a bit of softening of it or cropping tighter? The overall effect of the image is very soothing.

Nice looking abstract Huw! I do think the image is suggestive and has enough detail to tell you what it is, if you are used to viewing flowers up close. I like the effect, it would make a good decoration somewhere.

1 Like

ok will soften it in next version - thx

I love this kind of macro work, Huw. It’s one reason I’m loathe to dip my toes back into focus stacking (was into big time when I first got into macro). Or actually, maybe the reverse is true. I love this kind of macro work because I am loathe to do focus stacking. :rofl:

I see Dennis’s point about the anther in the upper right. I don’t know that I would have thought of it or noticed it otherwise, but I think it’s a fair point for both processing and which anther is in greatest focus next time. I’m not sure what’s optimal. If it were more central, we might have wondered why all the others were not in focus. Could be one of those catch-22 things.

Regardless, nice work. These look great printed big and placed somewhere that needs a pop of color without too many competing colors.

ML

The original poster added a revised version of their image.

This one does work better for me, Huw.
ML

1 Like

I do like what you did to that stray in the repost, Huw. Very nice work.

Regarding Revision 1:

Huw,

Most definitely I see this as a soff focus macro - and very nicely captured. To be honest, I don’t see the ICM here - but then, do I need to?

I would agree with the other comments and the revision is an improvement. For me however, both of the anthers on the right are mildly distracting. I think the beauty of the image are the softer ones in the center moving left. I don’t want to make such a drastic alteration of your image, but I think a lovely alternative would be without the two on the right. Just my .02.

Thanks Lon

The camera was moving so come of the blur was motion blur - but no the ICM was only for blur rather than anything more dramatic.

Thank you for your crop suggestions - simplicity is good and I like the way you are suggesting.

Thanks

Huw

I think the revision is an improvement, particularly lightening up those darker spots central in the frame.

1 Like

Thx @Jonathan_Cothron