El Capitan Meadow Fog (Yosemite NPN Gathering)

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

Yet another image taken on our recent NPN gathering in Yosemite for Fall colors. I believe this image in is El Capitan meadow looking opposite El Capitan towards Cathedral Rock at about 10am. but it could also be Cooks Meadow, I can’t remember. It had rained the day and the night before soaking the meadow with water and when the sun finally hit the meadow and warmed the meadow, it created this low hovering fog that lasted mere minutes.
Obscured behind the fog is a colorful grove or two trees with Fall colors

Feedback Requested

This is a single image, not focus stacked. I only had the foreground in focus and now after getting home and processing this one I’m unsure if I need more depth of field or if the fog that is obscuring the background doesn’t need to be in focus anyway? I should have focus stacked this but the scene was changing so rapidly that I only got a couple of shots anyway. The fog was rapidly moving horizontally and disappearing quickly. Definitely photographer error on my part but does it kill the image?

Technical Details

Camera: z8
Lens: 240120mm
Focal length: 76mm
Shutter speed: 1/125th
Aperture: f/16
ISO: 800
Flash: none

David, for me, this shows off the sunlit meadow and the fog created as the sun evaporates the prior night’s wetness. The hints of fall color and trees through the fog add interest to the top 1/3 without detracting from that lovely meadow.

Hi David,

Like Mark, I’m feeling the sunlit fog and loving the hint of fall color just barely showing through. I wouldn’t mind a little more salience in that fall color, but I don’t know. Perhaps that would reduce the mystery and the joy of only gradually being able to see it.

Nice work!

ML

This is real sweet, David! The meadow is sharp where it needs to be and the fog and the back ground cottonwood trees have enough definition to carry the scene. I also like the hint of the granite wall even though it dark (a good thing).

If you want the yellow trees to have more pop, you could increase their saturation just a bit. That’s not a nit, just a thought.

Beautifully done, sir!
-P

David,

The luminosity of the FG grasses is wonderful. The fog is nice as well. Both are bright and for me anyways, it makes it had to see past them into the trees and granite wall in the BG. I might consider raising the luminosity of the BG through a Dark-2 mask. I think it will help accentuate the atmosphere of the meadow and bring out those glorious trees.

Hi David,

No need for more DOF, in my opinion. I like the focus on the beautiful, warm vegetation in the FG. The fog takes away the sharpness anyway and you already used f/16 for maximum DOF.
I tried what it would look like if you changed the BG, raising the detail a bit. Just a thought.

The layering is very nice Dave, and the focus looks just fine to me. Having the background less than tack sharp may even be better here.

One other option, rather than pumping up the background, could be to soften the transition too it. That may rob from the fog too much, so maybe not. Anyway, here’s a visual example to compare (and I reduced the brightness of a few of those guys at the bottom edge):slight_smile:

Dave: I’ve decided that the best way for me to get caught up is to pick each participant and go through their submissions so I’m indulging myself with yours this morning. I did very few intimates so I’m really enjoying your vision. I like the comp and your exposure and DOF decisions. There is enough detail in the BG to make it interesting without it being a competitor to the grasses. I also like where you placed the “horizon” line. Most excellent. >=))>

Hi David

Lovely vision and execution. Love the composition, colours, focus and horizon position.

The horizon is just a little bright for me, so I would move a little towards John Williams working … but not quite that far.

Lovely

Huw

Dave,

Terrific image capturing one of those fleeting moments when the fog is dynamic and changing quickly! I don’t know how to explain it, but it’s almost like 2 different scenes disconnected, yet at the same time, they’re connected. (probably the stupidist thing I’ve written in a long while…) :roll_eyes: But for sure the detail in the grasses upfront kinda represent the here and now, and the misty backdrop from another time - or something like that.

Yeah, in hindsight maybe a focus stack would work better to bring these elements together. But I kinda like how they’re separated by the softer meadow grasses in front of the line of fog. I suppose the autumn colors in the mist could be emphasized a little bit more, but I think this works very well as a whole and as presented.

Nah, I think you did an excellent job in capturing and composing this, despite the rapidly changing conditions.