Critique Style: Standard
The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic + Technical
About This Image
My wife and I started our Zion trip last month with an overnight backpack through the Narrows. I decided to bring my big camera and tripod, but by the end of the first day, I was really tired and sore, so I didn’t take as many photos as I would have liked. However, the trip was incredible, and the fall color in the upper reaches of the Narrows was unbelievable.
Feedback Requested
This is certainly not a ground-breaking photo, but I like it. Interested to hear any and all comments you may have on ways to improve this. Thanks in advance!
Technical Details
Camera: Canon EOS R5
Lens: EF24-105mm f/4L IS USM
Focal length: 50mm
Shutter speed: 1/4s
Aperture: f/11
ISO: 100
Craig, you’ve got some fine fall colors here, as well as an interesting stream and amazing wall of rock. I’m struck by how brown the stream is. Was there recent rain? It looks like this was taken under an overcast sky, which is great for the colors and the details.
Hi Craig,
It sounds like your trip to Utah was productive. I haven’t been back since 2019, and I’m overdue. I love the color here and the sense of a churning river. Placing the river in the center definitely gives us the feeling of hiking the narrows. I’ve never done that myself (it’s cold and I’m old and don’t want to break a bone on a wet rock
).
I’m not sure if there are other compositional choices. I know what you mean about it not being ground-breaking, but of course, not everything has to be. The real question, I think, is whether it emphasizes what you hoped to emphasize. The fall color and the churning water come through loud and clear. Part of me can imagine a slight crop off the top, but part of “the narrows” is by definition “the height” of the walls, so any trimming up there has the potential to change our perception of the depth of this canyon.
Looking forward to reading the feedback from others here.
ML
Given the flash floods in the Southwest recently, I don’t think I’d venture into a place called the Narrows, but it looks like you had some fine weather for it. While the churning stream of water leads the eye straight to the color and the wall, it feels a bit too straight and blatant for my taste. I played with a rather radical crop that pretty much eliminates the stream, which may not be at all where you were going with this, but I’ll throw it out there just for fun.
Thanks @Mark_Seaver @Marylynne_Diggs and @Dennis_Plank !
I’m not sure about the weather before our hike. We got into Springdale on Saturday evening and left for the hike before sunrise the next day. I found the water to be very strange, it was a bit cloudy, but not full of sediment. If you were walking in it, you could see the rocks and your feet and things on the bottom. Later in the week when the rain came in, the river looked like chocolate milk. You couldn’t see through the water at all.
I do think I achieved that, which was the incredible fall color and the sense of place within the Narrows. I also appreciate that you say not everything has to be ground breaking…I agree.
It ended up working nicely for us. We originally had our Narrows hike scheduled for Wednesday-Thursday, but even before we flew out, the weather was looking bad, so we rescheduled for Sunday-Monday, and we’re glad we did, because big storms came through on Thursday and the Virgin River flooded the town of Hurricane, just downstream from Zion. We’re glad we were able to hike the Narrows when we did.
I can appreciate that this is too obvious a composition for your taste, I actually expected that type of response, and I don’t necessarily disagree. This is probably more of a pretty document of an amazing experience for me. In regards to your crop, it does go further than I was looking to go, but I appreciate you taking the time to critique and do the editing!
Glad you didn’t battle flooding! I remember many years ago backpacking in Buckskin Gulch and admiring how high up the slots above me that trees were wedged.
You caught a nice combination of canyon elements, and the fall color is excellent. I do wish the water wasn’t so brown, but you don’t get to pick and choose that!
Craig,
A wonderful and well composed autumn image from Zion NP. I’m with John in that I’m wishing the river wasn’t muddy, but of course that’s just part of the environment that we all know is there when it rains in the desert! No matter, the autumn scene is captured beautifully and the way you’ve composed the river obviously is a great lead-in.
Colors and processing look great and I can’t really think of how you could improve this. Very nitpicky, but I would clone the very small bright patch above the orange tree top ULC. Pretty picky I know. 
Thanks @John_Williams and @Lon_Overacker.
Lon, I think your cloning note was a good one, so I have incorporated that in my PSD file. Thanks!