Holding court (+revised)

Revised Version

Revision 1 (latest)

What changed: As recommended I played around with the framing a bit and added a bit to the right and took a bit off the bottom and a tiny bit off the top

Added after receiving feedback from the community.


Original Version

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

We were driving around in Bandhavgarh National Park searching for interesting wildlife and tigers. We had seen a tiger back in the brush but nothing close. We then rounded a corner and were delighted to see this beautiful cat. He was just relaxed and seemed to be looking out over his kingdom. Very regal. It was quite enjoyable just to sit for awhile and enjoy. Definitely a treat.

Feedback Requested

Interested on thoughts on the framing and composition. I appreciate any other comments. Thanks

Technical Details

Canon 7Dm2
EF 100-400
140mm
ISO 6400 f7.1 1/1600

This is an amazing image. Beautiful subject, regal pose and a perfect reflection. You might try cropping down a bit from the top . Thanks for sharing this.

Andrew, thanks. I appreciate your thoughts and advice. I’ll definitely try some framing alternatives.

Timothy, it’s a beautiful animal.

I would expect the reflection in the water to mostly match the scene on top. But I see foliage in the water that doesn’t appear on top. The leaves in the background on top don’t appear in the reflection. Was there something odd about the topography?

Don, thank you, that is a great observation. I didn’t even notice the discrepancy. I will review my editing and see if I can figure it out. I am a bit new to editing and processing my photos and I really appreciate all of your comments and feedback.

Simply gorgeous. Though I suppose more green in the frame would help the tiger pop even more, the fallen leaves do add a lovely complementary tone instead.

Max, thank you.

Hi Timothy

Another buck list photograph. Great color and eye contact. The reflection is a bonus. As for framing, I think you could look at adding some more room on the right side of the frame and taking off some on the bottom of the frame. The Tigers’ head and eyes are what are important and losing some of the grass would help the photograph.

Nice work.

Peter

Thanks Peter, I appreciate the recommendations and will play around with the framing a bit.

The original poster added a revised version of their image.

Beautiful setting, great subject and reflection too, I love them all. Somehow, I’m more happy with the original post.

@Don_Peters I was waiting for someone to answer your question, since it didn’t happen so here we are.

You don’t see foliage in the reflection because you are seeing the foliage from eye level but reflection of grasses you see is from water level. And tiger is sitting not very far from POV.

Thanks for the explanation, J.

Thanks J for your explanation.