M16 The Eagle Nebula

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic + Technical

About This Image

This is a re-processing of my attempt two years ago to capture the target @Dean_Salman posted yesterday, with a much simpler device. This target is very low in the south and in major light pollution for me. And it’s only high enough to get a little over an hour on it, so this is 3 nights combined – as was his. I managed a total of 4 hours on it. And I was never happy with it, due to the problems of light pollution and a low target, so I was interested to re-process it with the newer tools in PixInsight. I don’t remember if I had posted it before, but probably not, as I had never put it on my web site. So it’s just to compare with his SeeStar, which comes out looking surprisingly good. And a lot of the differences in the two images are just from various decisions made in processing.

Feedback Requested

All comments welcome!

Technical Details

My normal astro rig – 400mm refractor, SkyWatcher EQM tracker (now have a better one), ASI2600MC Pro camera, ASIAIR on-board computer, PixInsight processing outlined in my replay to Dean’s post. I didn’t bring out as much nebulosity outside the center as I had hoped, largely due to limitations of the light pollution. I should try the filter he used, and/or just get more time on the subject by combining more nights. Could probably push processing more, too.

I tried to add a revision above and that option is missing now, so I’ll just put it here – decided to re-process with less brightness to bring out the Pillars of Creation a little more. Although there is no comparison to what the Webb did, Dean’s image defined them better than I have managed here. I also cropped in more as the very dim nebulosity away from the main nebula is not very interesting.

Awesome images, Diane. I do like the revised version better as it really pops. Our 2-d presentations sure makeit look like space is crowded!

Diane, I know nothing about astro photography but the revised image is my favorite., when you zoom in to the image the detail is amazing. Beautiful.

Alice

Well done Diane, the contrast brought up nice detail. I need to add this to my RC 8 for next summer

Thanks @Dennis_Plank , @alice and @Dean_Salman ! Dean – :+1: Report back!!

Love this version @Diane_Miller !