Sunrise at the Laguna

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

Had our first rain of the season yesterday, so seems like a good time to channel some clearing fog opportunities with this older image.

Feedback Requested

All comments welcome!

Technical Details

Camera: Canon EOS 5D
Lens: EF70-200mm f/2.8L IS USM
Focal length: 160mm
Shutter speed: 1/3s
Aperture: f/11
ISO: 100

Not a lot done in LR – contrast lowered a bit and the sunbeams enhanced a lot in PS.

2 Likes

Very nice @Diane_Miller

Very atmospheric, highlights well controlled, nice tonal range amongst the mist, nice rays.

Nothing here not to like… Lovely

Huw

Diane, I love this light/dark, not quite black and white image. The strong blacks have a graceful movement, while the light rays add mystery and atmosphere. Beautiful all around.

Alice

This is absolutely wonderful, Diane. I love the crepuscular rays shining through the fog and everything framed by those lovely branches. My only nit, and I had to dig for it, is the brighter area above and to the right of the sun as illustrated. I’d be tempted to tone that area down ever so slightly.

Visual Notes

[A1] This area feels just a touch too bright. Almost likethere’s a second source of light.

Thanks, @Huw_Thomas , @alice and @Dennis_Plank ! Dennis, that area would be easy to tone down, and the brightest areas feel blown out. This is older processing and I should go back and look at a linear profile or some other remedy. The fog was breaking quickly and was ragged. As usual, I was a bit late to the show.

Visual Notes

This is such an arresting image. The burst of sunlight in all directions is what makes it for me. But what if it came from one direction? Actually there are many good crops in this image. Great work.

[Crop] an experiment

Hi Diane,

Moody and mysterious, I love this! The crepuscular rays are amazing; almost like the light leading me out of a dark and sinister place. No suggestions from me as this is beautifully done.

Whow, I first thought this was a burst picture, but then noticed that the trees and landscape were sharp. I very much like this kind of images. Have you also other pictures where you tried to hide the sun further behind a larger branch or trunk? Or would that kill the sunburst?
I also like the colour palette of this image.
Extremely well done again, Diane. Looking forward for more.

This is wonderful, Diane. I like it as is. Curious to see a revised version toning down the light, but to me, that area feels like drifting fog and adds to the atmosphere.

Nicely done,

ML

Thanks, @Igor_Doncov , @Ed_Lowe , @xavier1 and @Marylynne_Diggs ! This an oldie, from 2006! The Laguna de Santa Rosa is a lowland area that floods in heavy rains (in winter) and drains slowly over several days. If it clears off overnight it will usually be cold and if it is calm, fog will form in a very local area for a short time at sunrise. This was one of those lucky mornings when I guessed right about the conditions.

I have often tried to shoot sunbursts with just a sliver of sun behind branches and occasionally succeeded, and a few times I’ve managed it with fog, but this was my best result. That is a thick tangle of limbs in front of the sun, which helped. And the old 5D had a limited dynamic range, which maybe also helped.

It’s so old I’m not even sure I can find the raw file and I’m buried right now with a computer issue so probably won’t revisit it at that level. I just had to drag it out because it seemed so appropriate for my mood!

1 Like

Diane, I love everything about this image except for some weird dark areas. Maybe from processing?

Thanks, @Michael_Lowe ! Those areas are strange. I think I remember liking the weirdness at the time, but it’s not what I would strive for now. I only found a PS file with 2 layers, the top one being the lighter vignette on the right and bottom. It felt too heavy so I reduced its opacity before posting. I’ll look for the original – it would be fun to re-do – but I have a feeling it could be on one of the hard drives I didn’t have time to grab, fleeing from a 2017 wildfire while my husband was halfway across the country in an antique airplane. I’m still wishing I had made one last run upstairs but glad I didn’t try, as I was recovering from knee surgery and could barely walk for the next month. Between here and the edge of town, 6 miles, 22 people died that night.