The Brickmason

Actual orientation

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

Went on my normal garden tour this morning and scared up this little hackberry butterfly. I think it’s a female but can’t be sure. She flew up onto one of our crepe myrtle trees so I scurried back into the house and fetched the long lens rig. As I approached she took off but only went a few yards and landed on the side of the house. I got some record shots from a reasonable distance but was able to approach to my minimum focus distance using a 16mm extension tube. I also got the benefit of a small breeze moving the leaves in the trees behind me allowing little splashes of sunlight to pop through. The only problem was that same wind was jostling her just a little bit so motion blur fouled some of the shots but that’s why we have high frame rate cameras.

I decided to retrieve my 100mm macro and put the 2x on it with hopes she would let me get close enough for a tight portrait. The second shot was taken with the macro but since it only gave me 200mm of reach I couldn’t get close enough to get the full frame facial I was hoping for. So it goes.>=))>

Feedback Requested

The second shot was the actual orientation but I decided to flip the first 90° CCW so it looks like she is standing instead of hanging. I also much prefer the lighting on the first shot as there is just the hint of spotlighting on the face. The focus and detail with the macro lens is a bit finer but I had to crop more to get a similar proportion. Your preferences?

Technical Details

Sony A7rIII
Shot 1: Sony FE 70-200 f2.8 GM-II, 2x TC @ 400mm, 16mm XT
ISO 1600, 1/10 @ f22
Shot 2: Sony FE 100mm f2.8 GM Macro, 2xTC
ISO 1600, 1/13 @ f22

Sorry, Bill, but I prefer the macro shot. I’m not sure what changed, but the color balance is definitely different and I like it a bit better for that reason. I also like the head-down orientation and for may taste the light through the wings and antennae make up for the light on the face of the first.

Second for me too, Bill. Light, color and sharpness are all more pleasing to my eye there. I’d be tempted to clone out the diagonal stripe cutting across the wingtips in the BG as it pulls the eye a little. I also like the view of the rough tile perch in the second one, nicely balanced with the blurred BG to the right.