Right. I didn’t expect it to go in that direction. Here are the mods I made but did not post. I prefer a cooler approach but decided that was just personal taste and would not appeal to most people.
This brings up something I had been ruminating over. How valuable are verbal suggestions? I often get suggestions that I know the person critiquing would not have made if they had actually seen what they are suggesting. Changes are not obvious when you just look at an image. In addition, words don’t convey fully what the author intends to say. That’s because there are no words in any language that can describe every color. The same with tones. Crop suggestions, on the other hand, can be accurately conveyed in words. As a result the author of the image is really guessing to some extent what is being suggested. I also feel that a critique with displayed modifications should generate more interest and result in a more involved discussions. What say you @David_Kingham? Would that make NPN better?
