Critique Style Requested: Standard

The photographer is looking for generalized feedback about the aesthetic and technical qualities of their image.


The fall color has been excellent this year. This tree is one of many in a local cemetery.

Specific Feedback

Lack of full tree.

Technical Details

5DMKIV; 24/70 @24; 500ISO; 1/60th; 9.0; WB: daylight

Hi Jim! This tree sure has a nice variety of great fall colors! The reds, oranges and yellow are excellent, and all in a single tree. Nice image!

Steve, Thank you. Jim

That is an impressive tree. I don’t see any angle here other than documentary, but it’s got presence.

@_Kris Yep.

This is a beautiful tree all decked out in an array of autumn colors, Jim. The lack of a full tree does not bother me at all; in fact I could see going even tighter and getting rid of the blue sky. I was thinking something like this. Not necessarily better, just another option.

Ed, Thank you. I like your idea. Jim