@Bill_Leggett, @Alan_Kreyger, @Han_Schutten: Thanks!
Bill, I think this is exactly how I feel about that crop, too. I couldn’t see it until I saw it on @Brent_Clark’s crop. This has been a very useful discussion.
Han, there shouldn’t be a major change in tonality between the two although when you scroll one to the other it looks like the second is very much subdued. But if you click through them after enlarging one of them, it should be pretty similar (Thanks @Igor_Doncov for the tip!) .
I have made a second revision that I am very happy with. In addition to the crop, I added a very slight vignette and deepen the magenta although not quite as much as what Brent did. I want to stay with subtle. I have edited the original post for that.
What a great discussion.