The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive
About This Image
I was captivated by the reflections in this kettle pond along the Denali National Park road. I wanted to get closer, get the whole pond, get a perfectly symmetrical reflection, all to no avail. As it was, I bushwacked through thigh high blueberry and dwarf birch, tripped and fell several times (blueberry tundra offers the best face-plants imaginable), and this was my favorite of several.
Meanwhile, back at the road, my workshop buddies were shooting sand-hill cranes flying in front of snow-capped peaks at 600mm. Pshaw. Yeah, they came away with epic shots. I have a few cranes in the upper right and lower right corners, but this photograph is not as frame-worthy as what others got from the road looking the other direction.
Still, I like this reflection a lot. I like the color, the featureless sky and the fact that it is not symmetrical. That little peninsula saw to that.
Feedback Requested
Mostly I’m sharing for the Weekly Challenge, as it seems to fit: negative space, in between-ness. But I’m always interested in suggestions for better processing. In particular:
Is the featureless gray sky too much of a drawback?
Do you see a better crop?
How did I do with the color/luminosity treatment?
Thanks as always for any time you can spare for feedback on my work. Much appreciated,
ML
Technical Details
Canon 5D4 with 24-105mm at 105mm
ISO 320, f/11, 1/25
A very interesting take on the theme, Marylynne. I think the land colors work well and the plain sky, while not dramatic, works better for symmetry than clouds would have. I’m a bit ambivalent about the inclusion of the faint flock of cranes both in the sky and the reflection. They don’t really seem to add anything to the image for me (and I’m a bird photographer who happens to love that species).
Thanks, @Dennis_Plank . In all honesty, I didn’t see the cranes while shooting nor when I chose this as the best of the bunch of this subject. It was only when I started looking for things in the water that are distracting that I realized this was a flock of cranes. You would have loved the view from the road. My workshop makes got some cool stuff there.
ML
I like this rather unique looking composition. It’s not often that one sees such a colourful landscape sandwiched between such a light and uniform colour. I also like that you included that bit of land coming in from the right that adds more interest to the image than the background land and it’s reflection. Nicely seen!
As with your recent bear images, the colors in the landscape are just incredible. The combination of reds, oranges, yellows and greens is spectacular. What an experience! I struggled with the white sky and with the white reflection on the water and so I thought I would see what happens when I add a border or frame. To me, it looks much better and probably it could be improved with a different colored border.
Marylynne, the highly colored land and the symmetry of the reflection set against all that white makes a very striking and unusual view. The cranes are the kind of “visual surprise” that I like as it requires viewing on a large screen. It’s an intriguingly artistic view.
Like @Willemd, I was struggling with the white sky and the white reflection in the water until I saw what Willemd did by adding a frame to the image. What a difference. It’s all about the contrast and the colors to my eye. The flock of birds and their reflection I thought was a smudge on my computer screen before zooming in. Because they are blurry I don’t think they add much to the scene although it sounds like your workshop mates got some great images shooting the other direction. What do they always say in landscape photography…Don’t get locked into one composition and for goodness sake, turn around!!!
Although at first the textureless sky bothered me a little, the idea gradually grew on me, and I ended up liking that sky—especially after seeing it framed with a black border.
The composition looks great to me; I don’t feel any need to change the framing or the image’s proportions. The colors are vivid without being “too loud.”
What doesn’t work quite as well for me are the birds, which, at this scale and in the spot where they appear, look like dirt on the sensor.
All in all, a beautiful image.
In particular, thanks Willem for adding the frame. I never do that when posting because I figure I’ll be cropping and changing it anyway. It does make a difference. I tend to use the dark mode on light pictures, so I forget how bad it can look in the light mode.
David: Ironcially, or not, I knew what they were shooting (or at least I knew they were shoot cranes flying by), and just wasn’t as interested in that as I was in this. My max focal length was 400, so they got some things that would have required a lot cropping for me.
Mark, David, and Joao: I didn’t even see the cranes in the image until I was doing edge patrol and cleanup at 100%, thought they were bits of grass in the water, and realized they were birds. They definitely don’t add a lot. Maybe they detract a little. I was sure this pond was going to yield a great photograph. As it turned out, it’s on my B roll.