Sunset Over Sally's Cove, Newfoundland

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive

About This Image

There are a lot of reasons this photograph matters to me besides the finished photograph itself.
As was typically the case when we first visited Newfoundland last September, we discovered that we could camp pretty much anywhere we could park our truck/camper. Locals were fond of saying, “If you don’t see a sign saying, “no parking”, you’re welcome to camp". The only time we ever saw such a sign was one time in a National Park. Anyway, this picture was taken from one of those “you’re welcome” spots off a very lonely stretch of highway right by the ocean. We camped here for several nights and early on I thought there might be a picture right here, practically from where we’d parked. The first evening I had a hunch I might have a nice landscape if the clouds would just break and let the light of the low setting sun through. So, I did exactly as Sam Abell says: “Compose from back to front and wait”. What I thought I was waiting for was an opening in the clouds and sure enough I caught a break. But then, only moments after I took my first few shots, a lone truck came over the hill, and I realized that that was actually what I was waiting for. For me, the lights of that lone truck turned a very nice landscape into an excellent one. But that wasn’t the end of it. After that no other cars or trucks appeared, and the sun dropped below the clouds again. I was afraid I’d missed the shot (I couldn’t get a good look through the EVF and didn’t have access to another screen). So, I was determined to try again the next evening. And so, I did. I set up the shot exactly as I had the evening before – same time of day, same composition – and waited. Finally, a car’s lights poked over the rise. The car’s lights were perfectly placed and I made my photograph. But I later discovered that that photograph turned out to be a dud because I didn’t have the same fortuitous light as the evening before. Fortunately, as I discovered much later, I had gotten the shot the first time around. But the experience really drove home how photography is about the moment and that a moment can’t be replicated. Because it isn’t just about the composition but about so many other factors over which the photographer has no control. While luck favors the prepared, luck or synchronicity still and always will be a factor in making good pictures.

Feedback Requested

What I am aiming for in this image is a sense of melancholy as the day reaches its end. The solitary lights of the truck, the isolated unlit building on the hill, as well as the otherwise empty highway and the scattered boulders on the landscape all, I think, support that feeling. At the same time, I hope there is also a sense of refuge, of going home.
What is your sense of this image? What feelings does it evoke for you?

Technical Details

Camera:
Lens:
Focal length:
Shutter speed:
Aperture:
ISO:

Tripod/handheld:
Focus method:
Filters:
Technique:
Conditions:

Processing software:
Major adjustments:
Blending/stacking:
Other notes:

Camera:
Lens:
Focal length:
Shutter speed:
Aperture:
ISO:

Tripod/handheld:
Focus method:
Filters:
Technique:
Conditions:

Processing software:
Major adjustments:
Blending/stacking:
Other notes:

Camera:
Lens:
Focal length:
Shutter speed:
Aperture:
ISO:

I enjoyed reading about the experience photographing the scene. For me when I first saw the image and opened the larger image I had a very emotional response to the scene. It is one those that doesn’t have an amazing feature or vivid colors, but gives you a wonderful sense of place and records a great moment in time as the last light leaves the landscape. Really well seen. I like the little house and the car, you are right, it does add to the image. The only suggestion I might have would be to remove the water towers, they were a bit distracting to my eye, but that’s just a personal presence. Great work!

Kerry, this is nicely quiet and inviting. I do suggest trying to open up the foreground just slightly, although that might reduce the quiet feeling. The car lights are an interesting and important addition to the sense of place.

I think what I like about this image is its subtleness and also how different this is from what we normally see here at NPN. I didn’t understand what you were getting at here until I read your description. It’s time arrested as I understand it. A lone car on a country road on a barren landscape. At first I thought the should be bigger in the image with larger headlights but now I believe the point is that the car is small within the picture. I think you could come up with many thought stories about what is going on here. My thoughts all have to do with the car. Where is it going at this time of day?

Nice one, Kerry! Those car lights definitely make this image for me. The image (to me) is full of feeling and emotion. Your word to describe it, melancholy, hits it rights on the head. Ever since I was a child, I’ve had a complicated relationship with this time of day – the time the day turns to night, and it only happens if I’m outdoors. Of course, sunset light is beautiful, but I’ve always felt uneasy during this time. I often feel that I need to hurry to go inside before the dark comes, as if it’s not safe to be out at that time, though as soon as it’s dark that feeling vanishes, and I feel fine again. I don’t know where it comes from, but I’ve experienced this for as long as I can remember. I wonder why…

First of all, what a great read. Thanks for sharing the experience of this shot.

I love the composition. The rock placement in the lower left corner is perfectly placed. Without that rock, the composition falls apart.
I love the subtlety of everything in this image. The green grasses, the color in the sky, the rocks which are enough but not too much, and of course the small building dead center in the frame. I don’t see a highway or even a road and people passing through. I see a home on the range and it’s occupants getting home just before dark after being out all day. The car is subtle too. You notice the headlights straight away but they are not all you see. There is much more to the story than a pair of headlights.
As i zoom into the image, I notice the water towers and grain silos. They tell me that these people live out in the country and and quite possibly don’t have the luxuries in their home that most of us take for granted. Not necessarily isolated but maybe close.
Melancholy, Yes. I get it. While my take on this image doesn’t quite match yours, it does tell a story, perhaps many stories to each viewer.
I love that you can park your camper or truck almost anywhere in Canada. Not so in the states. I’m so envious.

Before discovering that this was an evening shot I fantasized that it was a fisherman that woke up at daybreak and is heading to the launch site for the day’s fishing. My neighbor in Baja gets up every day at 3:30 to pull up the lobster traps and set up new ones. He drives like this in the morning darkness to Punto Chivato. It’s a hard life but I always envied him for it. Sometimes he gives me a few lobsters when the work is done. In fact, if you’re camped at the point you will see headlights slowly making their way towards you just before daybreak just like this picture.

@Scott_Fricke - thank you for taking time with this photograph. It is gratifying that your experience in viewing it is so aligned with my intention in making it.
@Mark_Seaver - thanks for you feedback. You have suggested “trying to open up the foreground”. I don’t quite understand what “opening it up” would mean but more importantly for me, would be why you think that. Would it, in your view, help to better align this photograph with my intention for it? If so, why do you think so?
@Igor_Doncov - thanks for chiming in, Igor. It is a bit different for me as well and I even wondered whether it would be considered a landscape by some. It is always interesting to hear how others read an image and the stories that come to mind which can often be very different than what was on the photographer’s mind. In this case, your wondering about the car is quite in line with how I felt when making the picture.
@Tom_Nevesely - Thank you for your open and revealing comment on the dark. Psychologically speaking, the approaching dark is for many people anxiety inducing. It touches in, I think, to the primal fear of the dark that is more or less bred in the bone, and the vulnerability it implies for most humans. That this feeling comes up for you on viewing this image makes me think of it as a success.