The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.
Feedback Focus: Artistic / Expressive
About This Image
I was attracted to the stark simplicity of the grasses and their reflections in the lake. The water was still as it was early and the wind hadn’t come up yet. A bright, flat, gray sky made for a blank background that set off the grasses nicely. The lines and rhythm of the grasses make me think of an audio graph.
Feedback Requested
Any thoughts, opinions, or feelings are appreciated.
Wow, striking! I love the simplicity, the rhythm, the symmetry, and the ambiguity between the grasses and their reflections. The high key processing works well, though I wonder if it’s perhaps it’s a bit too high key for the grasses on the left? They seem a bit washed out to my eye. Great image, I’d love to hang it on my wall!
I agree with Cathy about the left-hand grasses - and I’d be inclined to clone out the small horizontal bit near the middle as it’s the only thing without a reflection. That said, I love this image, very restful and calm. I’d enjoy gazing at it when feeling stressed. I especially like the color contrast between grasses and reflections. Well done!
This is wonderful, Chris. I love the high key treatment and the golden glow of the backlit grasses. I’m notoriously bad about recognizing where things get clipped or too funky for printing, but the left grasses did not catch my eye. Don’t take my word for it though . It might be worth cloning out the horizontal piece in the middle mentioned by Mike, just to see what that does. I’m often amazed how things I didn’t notice, once removed, make a big difference.
This is one of those images that I could look at forever. I see new things in it each time. At one point this morning, in the dark with my coffee, it kind of took on a “halloween font” kind of vibe. That was brief. It’s mostly lovely and elegant, and the audio graph metaphor works wonderfully.
I always like this kind of image, Chris and usually see it with the reeds pretty dark. It’s a nice change and interesting to have them so luminous and it works surprisingly well with the high key background.
Chris, I really like the simplicity (and the glow) in this view. Having the grasses translucent fits the white rest of the scene (hard to call it background, since its in front also… ) The grasses and their reflections feel like ballet dancers.
The high key composition is very nice. One problem about boosting the exposure is a reduction in micro-contrast which softens details present. Using clarity in Adobe Camera Raw or Lightroom may do the trick in putting this image over the top. Well done…Jim
Ooh, this is very nice! I love the starkness, the strong contrast and the vibrant yellows here. Goes to show that you don’t need a lot of elements to make a successful image. Really well done!
Kris_Smith
(Kristen M Smith)
selected this as an Editor's Pick
17
Outstanding minimalist image with energy and deliberation in terms of composition and processing.