Too close for comfort

Critique Style: Standard

The photographer is looking for thoughtful feedback on the image as a whole, especially around the areas noted below.

Feedback Focus: Artistic + Technical

About This Image

We were in Sabi Sand game reserve and saw this white rhino at a waterhole. It was the first rhino we had seen and we were excited to just hang out a while. He was very relaxed. We were fascinated by how beat up he was. I liked this photo as I thought it showed some great textures and contrast.

Feedback Requested

Please provide any comments about the processing, composition and mood. Any other advice is always appreciated.

Technical Details

Canon 60D handheld
EF 100-400
400mm
ISO 400 f5.6
1/500

Hi Timothy,
What a wonderful opportunity to observe this animal in the wild. It clearly has the scares indicating a hard existence. Critique wise I think the crop is too tight, I would like to see more of the animal itself and its habitat.
Alice

Alice, thanks for your thoughts. I will continue to experiment with different framing and cropping.

1 Like

Hi Timothy,
Great title for this one, as it does feel sooooo close. I think Alice is on to something with a suggestion for a wider crop, but I also see the value of this one. To be honest with you, when I first saw it, I thought I was looking at an abstract of a rock face. I’m hoping you have lots of images of these rhinos. They would make a great series, with this one as an opener, and then with others with more body and more environment.

Nicely done,
ML

Thanks ML. I appreciate your thoughts. I was curious how the very close portrait would be critiqued. I will have to throw in some additional rhino photos.

Hi Timothy
The framing and use of Balck & white help sell the photograph. The viewer’s eye is drawn into the Rhino’s tusk.
Peter

Timothy: I like your unique approach to the subject as well as the black and white treatment. All of the animal’s nicks, scrapes and scars are evident. You were fortunate to see a rhino with a full horn as many have been cut to prevent poaching. Very well done!

Thanks Peter, appreciate your comments

Richard, thanks. We were fortunate to see the rhino fully tussled.