The photographer is looking for generalized feedback about the aesthetic and technical qualities of their image.
Description
or maybe that should be ligaments. This feels very medical. It is the innards of a decaying stump that was the base of a two trunk tree. My guess based on the size of the surrounding trees is that the logging was about 100 years ago, since the forest is very mature with lots of fallen timber and very little undergrowth.
Specific Feedback
I’m fascinated with how twisted and knobbed this interior of the tree was.
Technical Details
R5, 180 mm macro, 1/20 s, f/10, iso 800, tripod. A 20 shot stack for dof.
Critique Template
Use of the template is optional, but it can help spark ideas.
Vision and Purpose:
Conceptual:
Emotional Impact and Mood:
Composition:
Balance and Visual Weight:
Depth and Dimension:
Color:
Lighting:
Processing:
Technical:
Very cool find and well photographed, Mark. If this is a horizontal section, it almost looks as if there was a whole clump of little trees that ended up merging together somehow. Any idea what the species might have been?
I wouldn’t have thought of bones, but now that you mention it I see exactly what you mean. Nor would I normally think of trees as having bones, but it’s really an interesting concept to consider. Fascinating image.
A really nice find and photograph, Mark. Now that you mention it, it does remind me of bones. It’s amazing how long a stump, especially of some types of trees, can hang around. Lots of shapes and textures in this.
Mark: A fascinating and fine find indeed. I like the various textures and lines. One can see what this may be but it is still wonderfully abstract. Well seen and superbly captured and presented. >=))>
Wonderful!! Maybe trees get arthritis too? Whatever it is and however it got to be the way it is, you have captured a wonderful and very interesting image! Congratulations on the EP – very well-deserved!
The bare bones thought is so good. You’ve seen it, captured it and processed it very well. I would have found it difficult to get a pleasing composition, but you’ve nailed it!
This is not only fascinating, but artistically compelling. Wood is naturally amazing, and I love seeing its variable rates of decay as you’ve captured so beautifully here. It comes to life even in death! I appreciate the DOF that you achieved with focus stacking. I’m curious to know where this was taken and what you know about the species.
Mark, I’m also late on posting on this scene. This is extremely fascinating with the overall oddities in twists, turns, knobbles and hobbles. Almost gives the aerial look over a twisting maze. Excellent image and congratulations on the Editors Pick too…
Elizabeth, this was taken in my “yard”, which is a mature forest of mostly hickory, oak and maple. There’s enough decay in this stump that I can’t ID it, plus I’m not good at tree ID from the bark only. It is a hardwood,
