Good job finding it on that isolated blackberry cane, David. This is a very good silhouette with that distinctive beak so clearly shown. It may just be me, but I find myself wanting the whole image shifted just a hair down in the frame. Other than that minor nit, I love it.
Bravo on getting this all to line up and get the bird to pose! I really like it. The bold shapes are at once totally in silhouette, but equally recognizable. Even if you hadn’t said it was a RWBB I’d have guessed. The recrop might have the lowest branch a tad too close, but you could clone part of it away and no one would notice. Very spiky!
Very cool idea and execution! I like the added headroom at the top in the second version, but the LRC makes me nervous with the 2 spurs so close to the edge. Maybe just add canvas on top? Or clone the spurs if you want to keep the aspect ratio.
Way to think outside the box! Good pose showing off the beak and helping to ID the bird. I like the perch with the symmetry and like the second crop the best. Good job, but looking forward to some sun here in the Northwest.